Barzilla’s Presentation Part I

Scott Barzilla’s Presentation Part I

at the 4th Annual SABR Rogers Hornsby Chapter Winter Meeting, Jan. 23, 2010

at Texas State University-San Marcos

 

Catchers

 

 

WS

WARP3

WAR

PWS

PWARP3

PWAR

Total

Johnny Bench

118.67

105.9

71.2

92.33

89.1

59.5

536.7

Gary Carter

112.33

98.9

66.2

87.67

85

58

508.1

Yogi Berra

125

90.1

61.6

92

70.1

49.2

488

Ivan Rodriguez

108.67

100.5

66.6

76

82.1

50.1

483.97

Carlton Fisk

122.67

93.4

67.5

80

62.2

47.5

473.27

Mike Piazza

109

77.4

59.1

90

69.1

51.9

456.5

Bill Dickey

104.67

88.5

54.3

78.33

67.9

44.2

437.9

Joe Torre

105

80.4

55.5

81.33

66.5

45.4

434.13

Gabby Hartnett

108.33

91.2

50.1

76.33

67.8

39.5

433.26

Mickey Cochrane

91.67

70.1

51.1

83.33

65.6

47.2

409

Ted Simmons

105

63.5

50.8

80

53.8

46.2

399.3

Buck Ewing

80.33

83.4

51.4

65.33

71.7

43.8

395.96

Jorge Posada

81.67

63.9

44.3

74.67

61

43.1

368.64

Gene Tenace

77

58.6

48.6

69

54.4

45.1

352.7

Bill Freehan

89

57.6

43.4

74.67

48.9

38.9

352.47

Lance Parrish

82.67

67.9

35.6

64.67

56.6

32.1

339.54

Thurman Munson

68.67

57.9

43.3

68

57.1

42.9

337.87

Jason Kendall

79.33

54.7

37.1

65.33

52.8

36.4

325.66

Roy Campanella

69

56.1

36.3

69

56.1

36.3

322.8

Roger Bresnahan

77

52.7

42.2

65.33

45.9

37.8

320.93

Wally Schang

81.67

57.4

43.7

57.33

40.2

33

313.3

Darrell Porter

74

53

40.7

60.33

46.6

35.9

310.53

Charlie Bennett

52.33

70.2

37.7

43.67

63.5

33.9

301.3

Ernie Lombardi

72.67

55.1

39

55.67

44.9

30.9

298.24

Ray Schalk

63.67

54.2

22.6

55.67

51.5

22.6

270.24

Rick Ferrell

68.66

45.8

22.9

50

35.4

20.1

242.86

 

First Basemen

 

 

WS

WARP3

WAR

PWS

PWARP3

PWAR

Total

Lou Gehrig

163

113.7

118.3

128

92.6

96.4

712

Jimmie Foxx

145

94

94

108.33

74.1

76.1

591.53

Frank Thomas

135

105.3

75.9

100

83.1

60.2

559.5

Jeff Bagwell

129

97.2

79.9

99.33

80.8

65.7

551.93

Cap Anson

127

115

99.2

76

66.2

59.3

542.7

Roger Connor

121

102

87.1

86.33

74.7

66.6

537.73

Dan Brouthers

118.33

92.8

83.7

89.33

75.5

67.5

527.16

Eddie Murray

145.67

96.4

66.7

91

69.2

51.8

520.77

Johnny Mize

112.67

80.2

70.1

98.67

72.6

64.4

498.64

Rafael Palmeiro

131.33

96.1

65.7

85.67

61.3

49.9

490

Willie McCovey

136

74

65.1

95

63.9

54.8

488.8

Mark McGwire

114

79.9

63.2

94.33

68.1

55.3

474.83

Dick Allen

114

70

61.1

101.33

65.4

58.5

470.33

Harmon Killebrew

123.67

70.9

61.2

93

58.5

51.2

458.47

Jim Thome

117.33

69

66.9

87.67

53.9

55

449.8

Keith Hernandez

110.33

69.1

61

86

62.1

53.7

442.23

Will Clark

110.33

74.4

57.4

89.67

61.9

47.3

441

John Olerud

100.33

80

56.6

79

63.9

49.2

429.03

Tony Perez

116.33

69.1

50.3

83

55.1

44.9

418.73

Fred McGriff

114

65.6

50.5

81

52.5

45.3

408.9

Hank Greenberg

89

58.9

56.9

87.33

58.3

56.2

406.63

Orlando Cepeda

103.33

65.1

46.6

83.67

57.4

42.6

398.7

Jason Giambi

103

51.2

52.7

89.67

48.7

50.7

395.97

Bill Terry

92.67

53.9

55.3

86.33

51.7

54.4

394.3

Jake Beckley

106

67.4

61.4

64.67

48.5

43.4

391.37

George Sisler

97.33

50.3

50.4

79.67

53.3

51.9

382.9

Frank Chance

79

47.7

49.4

71

42.9

45.1

335.1

Jim Bottomley

86

38.5

32.3

71.33

37.9

33.1

299.13

George Kelly

64.33

23.6

24.1

59.33

25.7

26.3

223.36

 

Second Basemen

 

 

WS

WARP3

WAR

PWS

PWARP3

PWAR

Total

Eddie Collins

191.33

137.8

126.7

125.33

96.3

87.6

765.06

Rogers Hornsby

167.33

128.6

127.7

127

101.3

100.8

752.73

Joe Morgan

170.67

127.4

103.5

113.67

91.8

78.1

685.14

Nap Lajoie

165.33

125.9

104.1

111.33

93.1

75.4

675.16

Charlie Gehringer

127.67

84.7

80.9

97

69.7

67

526.97

Craig Biggio

142.67

90

65.9

98

67.8

52.4

516.77

Rod Carew

128

85.8

79.3

87

67

61.3

508.4

Frankie Frisch

122

83.3

74.7

85.33

65.3

60

490.63

Bobby Grich

109.67

92.4

67.6

84.33

79.1

55.9

489

Lou Whitaker

117

103.3

69.6

77.33

69.9

48.1

485.23

Roberto Alomar

123.67

81

63.6

92.67

69.9

53.1

483.94

Ryne Sandberg

115.33

75.8

61.8

93

68.8

53.9

468.63

Jeff Kent

113

80

59.4

83.33

61.4

47.1

444.23

Jackie Robinson

85.67

67.9

63

85.67

67.9

63

433.14

Billy Herman

99.33

77.8

55.5

81

66.5

46.4

426.53

Willie Randolph

104

70.7

60.4

73.67

56.4

45.8

410.97

Bid McPhee

101.67

77.7

57.8

67.33

53.5

46.2

404.2

Joe Gordon

80.67

67.4

54.9

77.67

65.8

53.6

400.04

Bobby Doerr

93.67

72.7

48

78

62.2

43.3

397.87

Nellie Fox

101.33

63.4

44.6

73.33

60.2

42.6

385.46

Tony Phillips

89.33

69.1

47.8

66.33

59.4

40.1

372.06

Cupid Childs

79.67

58.4

47.1

75.33

55.9

46.4

362.8

Tony Lazzeri

84

57.9

48.1

71.67

54.2

42.6

358.47

Chuck Knoblauch

78

57.4

41.1

73

57.8

41.8

349.1

Larry Doyle

96.33

41.7

47.3

80

37.7

40.5

343.53

Johnny Evers

89.33

46

48.3

75.33

42.5

39.4

340.86

Red Schoendienst

87.33

57.9

40.3

68

48

35.9

337.43

Bill Mazeroski

73

51.5

27

57.67

46.2

25.9

281.27

 

Third Basemen

 

 

WS

WARP3

WAR

PWS

PWARP3

PWAR

Total

Mike Schmidt

155.67

122.7

108

122

92.5

81.9

682.77

Eddie Mathews

150

122.2

98.2

111

96

75.8

653.2

Wade Boggs

131.33

116.6

89

97

90.4

71.1

595.43

George Brett

144

112.4

84.9

98.67

82.6

67.7

590.27

Paul Molitor

138

108.8

74.9

90

75.1

54.2

541

Chipper Jones

123

72.4

76.7

83.67

59.6

60.9

476.27

Ron Santo

108

72.7

66.4

91.67

70.5

63.4

472.67

Edgar Martinez

101.67

88.2

67.2

81.67

72.4

58.1

469.24

Brooks Robinson

118.67

70.3

69.2

82.33

58.1

54.8

453.4

Frank Baker

100.33

69.6

63.7

93.33

65.6

60.3

452.86

Robin Ventura

91.33

96.6

55.1

77.76

80

46.7

447.49

Graig Nettles

107

80.2

61.3

74.67

59.2

49.9

432.27

Darrell Evans

121

62.1

57

84.33

53.1

51.9

429.43

Stan Hack

105.33

74.4

54.8

85.33

61.9

45.7

427.46

Jimmy Collins

91.33

68.7

52.9

80.67

64.7

49.5

407.8

Scott Rolen

91

74.7

62.2

81.33

63.5

53.3

426.03

Sal Bando

94.33

56.3

60.5

83.67

54.3

57.2

406.3

Ken Boyer

93

62

58.3

78.33

56.2

53.7

401.53

Bob Elliott

95.67

66.3

52.2

78.67

58.2

45.7

396.74

Buddy Bell

100.33

63.2

60.7

70

53.6

45.3

393.13

Heinie Groh

90.67

68.8

46.4

81

59.3

43.8

389.97

Ron Cey

93.33

55

51.8

74

51.7

46.2

372.03

Toby Harrah

95.67

54.7

47

75.67

52

42.5

367.54

Pie Traynor

91.33

63.9

37

76

56.1

38.1

362.43

John McGraw

69

54.5

49.1

66.67

53.6

48

340.87

George Kell

76.33

40.4

33.5

64

36.1

31.8

282.13

 


Shortstop

 

 

WS

WARP3

WAR

PWS

PWARP3

PWAR

Total

Honus Wagner

218.33

158.7

134.7

140.67

104

92.6

849

Alex Rodriguez

140.67

101

99.1

109.67

81.6

82.1

614.14

Cal Ripken Jr.

142.33

113.5

89.8

92

76.1

67.5

581.23

Robin Yount

141

104.5

76.8

92.67

80.5

59.2

554.67

Arky Vaughan

118.67

100.3

75.6

102.67

87.7

66.7

551.64

George Davis

132.67

94.4

90.7

85

68.5

63.1

534.37

Barry Larkin

115.67

98.8

68.8

86

83

54.8

507.07

Luke Appling

126

86.7

68.9

91.67

68.4

56.1

497.77

Bill Dahlen

131.33

88.5

75.9

83.33

60.6

53

492.66

Monte Ward

136.33

73.7

64.5

102.67

60.3

49.3

486.8

Ozzie Smith

108.33

105.5

64.7

75.33

78.2

50.4

482.46

Alan Trammel

106

93.6

66.8

79.33

74

56

475.73

Joe Cronin

111

78.7

62.6

91.67

69.7

54

467.67

Ernie Banks

110.67

74.8

64.3

82.33

67.6

60

459.7

Derek Jeter

116

61.4

68.7

91

51

57.6

445.7

Lou Boudreau

92.33

82.6

55.9

85

75.9

53

444.73

Bobby Wallace

115

72.8

65.8

75.67

60.4

50.5

440.17

Pee Wee Reese

104.67

71.3

66.4

82

57.7

55.1

437.17

Jack Glasscock

87

74.1

58.1

67.67

60.4

47.8

395.07

Joe Sewell

92.33

62.7

48.1

77.67

55.8

42.7

379.3

Tony Fernandez

93.33

71.6

39.4

73

59.3

34.6

371.23

Luis Aparicio

97.67

57.4

49.8

64.33

49

39

357.2

Dave Bancroft

89.67

51.7

46.3

74

47

44.1

352.77

Vern Stephens

88.33

50.5

43.4

79.67

47.9

39.5

349.3

Hughie Jennings

71.33

56.5

47.9

68

55.7

48.4

347.83

Joe Tinker

86

51.8

49

70.33

45

41.4

343.53

Phil Rizzuto

77

53.2

41.6

72.67

50.5

40.8

335.77

Rabbit Maranville

100.67

49.6

38

69

41.8

34.3

333.37

Travis Jackson

70.33

47.3

43.3

63.67

49.1

43.5

317.2

 

Left Fielders

 

 

WS

WARP3

WAR

PWS

PWARP3

PWAR

Total

Barry Bonds

234.67

192.6

171.4

142

119.6

106.6

966.87

Stan Musial

201.33

152.8

127.9

126

100.6

86.2

794.83

Ted Williams

185

128.2

125

131.33

97.2

93.4

760.13

Rickey Henderson

178.33

155.8

113.1

102.67

95

74.1

719

Pete Rose

182.33

106.4

75.4

102.33

73.7

58.5

598.66

Carl Yastrzemski

162.67

94.8

88.5

95.33

63

64.5

568.8

Ed Delahanty

118.33

84.7

74.6

97.67

77

70.9

523.2

Tim Rains

130

94.2

64.9

91.67

65.3

51.4

497.47

Fred Clarke

133.33

81.1

73.4

91.33

57.4

53.8

490.36

Jesse Burkett

129.67

73.3

63.8

94.33

60.9

52.8

474.8

Manny Ramirez

132.33

73.1

66.2

95

53.3

50.7

470.63

Al Simmons

125

71.4

63.5

95.33

59.2

55.5

469.93

Willie Stargell

123.33

82.2

57.5

87.67

66.4

47.8

464.9

Joe Jackson

98

60.1

62.9

96.67

56.4

61.6

435.67

Goose Goslin

118.33

61.8

62.9

87.67

52.9

51

434.6

Billy Williams

124.67

59.3

57.2

93

49.5

48

431.67

Sherry Magee

118

59.4

59.1

90.67

51.4

49

427.57

Joe Medwick

104

67

56

89

60

50.5

426.5

Zack Wheat

126.67

61.8

57.7

88

48

43.5

425.67

Jose Cruz

104.33

72.7

52.3

79.67

60.6

44.2

413.8

Jim O’Rourke

101.67

94.4

54

65.67

62.4

35.1

413.24

Jimmy Sheckard

113

63.9

51.7

85.67

55

42.6

411.87

Joe Kelley

101.67

59.9

55.4

80.67

56.6

49.8

404.04

Lou Brock

116

54.4

39.1

85.67

46.6

35.7

377.47

Albert Belle

81

61.9

37.1

79

62.1

37.6

358.7

Jim Rice

94

55.1

41.5

77.67

50.2

39.9

358.37

Ralph Kiner

80.67

47.9

45.8

80.67

47.9

45.8

348.74

Heinie Manush

95

31.1

43.9

78.67

31.9

39.3

319.87

Chick Hafey

62

31.8

29.4

58.67

32.2

30.2

244.27

 

 

 

 

Leave a Reply